Who stole the eggs in Onyx Storm? Rebecca Yarros told us…

Last updated:

Written by: Cory

Who stole the eggs in Onyx Storm? Rebecca Yarros told us...

Traditionally “hidden in plain sight,” Rebecca Yarros has already dropped hints for Onyx Storm, and the War Games in Fourth Wing hold a significant clue.

First and foremost, shoutout to our one and only Zuzzle for putting together this theory on the main Facebook page and to BalanceofProb from Reddit for coming up with it! I’m re-reading Fourth Wing for our read along but can I just say: this is an excellent theory!

Let’s go back to Fourth Wing for a bit.

In Fourth Wing, Chapter 28, the War Games are not just a training exercise but a symbolic preview of what’s coming in the main story, especially in Onyx Storm. Here’s how they connect:

The War Games and the Battle of Draithus

The War Games take place in the first half of May, the same time as the Battle of Draithus. This timing isn’t just coincidental; it’s a setup for what will unfold later. It mirrors the bigger battle and foreshadows the events that follow. Do you remember? The Fourth Wing needed to steal a crystal egg (guarded by three Elders) while successfully defending their flag.

So who stole the eggs at the end of Onyx Storm? Probably Xaden and Garrick…

Violet and Xaden’s Bond

During the War Games, Violet loses her connection with Xaden because they’re physically too far apart. This moment hints at how their bond will be challenged later in the story when they are separated by even greater distances. The separation here shows how deeply their connection affects them.

The Squads and Their Roles

In the War Games, Violet’s squad is tasked with defending a flag, while Xaden’s team has to steal the egg. These two teams mirror the roles each character plays later on. Violet’s squad is protecting something important (just like they will later defend Tyrrendor), and Xaden’s squad is attacking or pursuing something (like retrieving the eggs in Onyx Storm). These roles set the stage for their personal missions.

Protective Symbols – The Saddle and the Ring

Xaden gives Violet a saddle right before the War Games begin, which is meant to protect her during the exercises. Similarly, he gave her an emerald ring earlier in the story, which is also meant to safeguard her. After all, being a duchess, is a lot of protection…
These objects symbolize Xaden’s care for Violet and the protection she’ll need in future battles.

Dain’s Mission

Dain, who is part of Violet’s squad, is given the task of defending the flag in the War Games. This mirrors his role in Onyx Storm, where he’s involved in protecting important elements, like Tyrrendor, showing his loyalty and commitment to defending others.


In short, the War Games aren’t just about training; they are a preview of the much bigger and more dangerous challenges that Violet, Xaden, and their friends will face later (in Onyx Storm). They offer subtle clues about character dynamics, the themes of protection, and the symbolism of key objects like the saddle and the ring.

So, when you read Chapter 28, think of it as the story’s way of preparing us for understanding those missing 12 hours from the end of Onyx Storm. I cannot wait to add it to the read along!!!

Share that Venin and Wyvern are real!


4 responses to “Who stole the eggs in Onyx Storm? Rebecca Yarros told us…”

  1. I have this new theory recently about who stole the eggs. So at the end of OS we find out that 6 eggs are missing and 3 elders have been killed. Most of the fans assume that Garrick and Xaden took them to Unbriel to make a deal BUT hear me out. Isn’t it weird that 3 elders have been killed? Since when are the riders killing dragons??? It is against their principles. I mean have you seen how horryfied were they when Marlis ask them for dragon eggs? And I just can’t see the riders especially Violet,Xaden, Garrick and whoever was on this stealing eggs! I don’t think they will be ok with that and neither their dragons! So who stole them? I believe venin had a role her. At the end of OS we also learn that alloy daggers can kill dragons, Berwyn showed us killing Pancheck’s dragon and then wanted to kill Sgaeyl. I would not even said how scared I am with this but moving on I think some venin slipped in the vale above Riorson’s House during the battle or maybe after wanted to take some eggs to do some magic venin stuff with them. But 3 elders were guarding the eggs so those adorable little venin killed them and took the eggs! Now they might be some people in Navarre’s leadership who are venin or work with them or not. But I think they will make to look that Xaden took the eggs and blame him!(which I’m pretty sure more people know he is a venin and this really doesn’t help). If I think Xaden go to take the eggs back? Yes that is one of the possibilities. I think he might go to the venin academy (i don’t know how to tell it) and find out what are those little precious things doing there. Oh and i also think that the dagger that Theo throw it at Jack F Barlowe’s chest will release him.

  2. I’m not sure why, but for some reason, I wonder if it was the Irid’s that stole the 6 eggs.
    They can blend in with their surroundings, so maybe they snuck in and took them either to protect them in case the humans and dragons lost against the venin, or, to see if they could raise them to be peaceful like themselves, just like how leaving Andarna to be raised by the other kinds, caused her to be more like those she grew up around than like the rest of her kind?
    Could be partly why Andarna returned too maybe?
    I don’t think they killed any of the Dragons doing this though, being that they’re peaceful, and it didn’t say where the elders died exactly, just that there were 3 dead elders.

  3. I think Kaori has something to do with the missing eggs and the missing eggs are a way to get the the feather tails and ultimately the “gifts” feather tails possess. In 4th wing the squads were instructed to steal something the enemy would need. They still a high ranking officer uniform, KAORIS book on dragons, a SCRIBE, and the map from violets moms office.

    Kaori is a dragon nerd but I also believe Kaori is the new brother in onyx storm. Given his close proximity to Xaden as a professor and he is one of the 7 in the room while Brennan strategizes during the end of onyx storm. Garrick & Bodhi don’t have a reason to turn, they are very secure in themselves but they are exhausted from battle. Garrick and body are likely with Xaden but not venin. They haven’t turned this entire time theirs no point in turning now. Xaden is gonna get blamed for some crimes that are not his. Kaori would really be a plot twist and being an illusionist would be able to be used against Xaden, even frame him. The general consensus is Kaori is a well liked professor, even comes to violets add with Varrish after going AWOL for Xaden. But the truth about Kaori remains to be seen. His reason for turning? No idea. But being an illusionist isn’t helping much in battle, he also flies to Aretia with pancheck so I think he went with pancheck to see Berwyn and turned then for some hopefully interesting reason.

    1. Interesting theory. I was thinking of who could possibly be at Basgiath, who would know about Xaden yet not be considered a brother by Xaden, that would be a new intel for Berwyn, since he no longer cares for Jack.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About

Hello! This site is dedicated to the Empyrean Series by Rebecca Yarros. I’ve made this place to explore the rich world of Empyrean, full of characters, theories, and places. Each post is carefully researched and updated with the newest details from the series. This site is also a great spot for discussing theories about the Empyrean Series. 🐉
Read More